USA: A team of researchers from the Geothermal Exchange Organization, Oklahoma State University and Oak Ridge National Laboratory, have concluded that geothermal heat pumps (GHP), outperform variable refrigerant flow (VRF), in regard to the energy performance of heating and cooling systems within a commercial building environment.
The data was gathered and analyzed over a two-year period at the Atlanta headquarters of the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE), where researchers created a “living lab”, to assess the relative performance of GHP and VRF systems.
In order to be suitable for the experiments, a building at ASHRAE’s headquarters was renovated and enlarged to be able to include the different systems. As a result, the renovation resulted in a VRF system on the first floor, a ground source heat pump system on the second floor, and using a dedicated outdoor air-system for both floors.
Over 1,600 sensors were added during the renovation to monitor heating, air-conditioning and ventilation operations and conditions within the building. The sensors data showed that in comparison to geothermal, the VRF system used twice the amount of energy, and when heating and cooling load differences were normalized, the GHP system used 44% less energy than VRF.
Jeff Spitler, one of the researchers on the project and a professor of mechanical engineering at Oklahoma State University, said that “Though the control strategy for the VRF system resulted in longer run times compared to the geothermal system, it is clear that the ground loop water supply temperatures were more favorable than ambient air temperatures for heat pump operation. This allows the geothermal equipment to operate at higher efficiencies.”
During the two-year period of study, while maintaining similar zone temperatures, the geothermal heat pump system used 63% less energy in the winter period and 29% less energy in the summer, compared to the variable refrigerant flow system.
UK: Geoscart, formerly Greenfield energy, a UK-based geothermal energy company has secured £15m from Macquarie Lending to roll out its technology, which integrates geothermal energy generation, heat pumps, and solar thermal panels, at 15 Sainsbury’s stores this year, with further financing lined up to expand the business over the coming years.
Sainsbury’s has now moved Geoscart from a technology trial and bedding in period to a full “business-as-usual” rollout.
Greg Davis of Geoscart commented, "As a central part of that, we have had to set up a full finance/delivery relationship with British Gas and Macquarie, to enable the full self-funding rollout across a target of 100+ stores. Macquarie provides the necessary finance; while British Gas stands behind the technology and installed systems – both to Macquarie and the client – for their installed life."
Geoscart is working with British Gas to deploy the systems for Sainsbury's, but also hopes to work with other corporate clients in the longer term as the market for the technology grows.
"This marks the next stage in Geoscart's growth," said Geoscart chief exective Grahame Newton in a statement. "We developed the baseline technology from the oil and gas sector and have successfully applied it to the retail-consumer space. We are looking forward to rolling out the technology to a wider audience with the help of our operational partners."
Nikolaus Woloszczuk, co-head of Macquarie Lending Europe, said it was pleased to be supporting an "an exciting development" in the area of distributed and renewable energy finance.
"We are pleased to support the upscaling of emerging technologies that allow users to lower energy bills and minimise carbon emissions on a mass scale," he added.
Paul Crewe, head of sustainability, engineering and energy at Sainsbury’s said the supermarket was "delighted" to be at the forefront of the technology.
"I hope that with Geoscart’s help we’ll now see more retailers following suit," he said.
Sainsbury's have already installed 14 geothermal and heat pump systems at its stores and is planning to roll out to 100 stores over the next three to four years incorporating the use of natural refrigerant CO2 refrigeration systems.
About Geoscart: Formerly Greenfield Energy, Geoscart are leaders in thermal energy management technologies, design, install and operate thermal energy networks sustainably and efficiently, through geo-coupling.
Geo-coupling is a system that is coupled to the subsurface rock via pipes and heat exchangers.
USA: ClimateMaster, a leading manufacturer of geothermal and water-source heat pumps, in conjunction with Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), received the Federal Laboratory Consortium's (FLC) 2014 Award for Excellence in Technology Transfer for its Trilogy™ 40 geothermal heat pump system.
Raj Hiremath, ClimateMaster Director of Marketing said; "We are honoured to have received such a prestigious award from the FLC, which further underscores the groundbreaking success of our Trilogy series of geothermal heat pump systems, providing the industry's leading efficiencies that now achieve upwards of 45 EER in accordance with AHRI standards," as a company we are also proud to provide an example of the successes that can be achieved by partnering with federal and academic entities to develop commercially viable solutions that are scalable and effectively applied in real-world situations."
The Trilogy 40 geothermal heat pump system, released commercially in 2012, paved the way for the Trilogy 45™ Q-Mode™ variable-speed geothermal heat pump system. Trilogy 45™ provides the industry's highest efficiencies of 45 EER and saves even more energy via on-demand hot water generation capabilities.
The system also offers easy programming, monitoring and control for homeowners and dealers over the internet from any WiFi-enabled device.
In addition to the highest efficiency ratings, the Trilogy 45 Q-Mode's patent-pending Q-Mode technology reduces hot water operating costs by providing full-time, year-round domestic hot water heating at over 500-percent (5.0 COP) efficiency.
The Trilogy 45 Q-Mode is ENERGY STAR Tier 3-qualified, and exceeds requirements for the currently uncapped 30-percent federal tax credit for geothermal heat pump systems. Available in vertical-upflow, vertical-downflow and horizontal configurations, the system is also offered in 0930 kBtuh (9k to 30k Btuh, or .75 tons to 2 tons) and 1860 kBtuh (18k to 60k Btuh, or 1.5 tons to 5 tons) capacities. The Trilogy 45 Q-Mode is exclusively available through ClimateMaster GeoElite Dealers.
About Federal Laboratory Consortium (FLC): The Federal Laboratory Consortium for Technology Transfer (FLC) is the nationwide network of federal laboratories that provides the forum to develop strategies and opportunities for linking laboratory mission technologies and expertise with the marketplace. Organized in 1974 and formally chartered by the Federal Technology Transfer Act of 1986 to promote and strengthen technology transfer nationwide, the FLC recognizes approximately 300 federal laboratories and centres and their parent departments and agencies as current members.
About ClimateMaster: ClimateMaster, Inc. is the, which are considered to be the most energy efficient and environmentally friendly type of heating and cooling systems available on the market today. Headquartered in Oklahoma City, Ok, ClimateMaster, Inc. is a wholly owned subsidiary of LSB Industries, Inc. whose common stock is traded over the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol LXU.
USA: IKEA have announced that all underground geothermal work is complete for its future Kansas City-area store scheduled to open in fall 2014.
The store will be the largest single building with geothermal heating and cooling in either Kansas or Missouri.
The underground work for this geothermal system involved drilling 180 boreholes, 600 ft deep into the earth across part of the 19-acre IKEA site. Pipes placed into these boreholes will circulate 36,000 gallons of heat transfer fluid (a water-based, anti-freeze solution) that will connect to 64 heat pumps to heat and cool the store. The system will also include five hot-water heat pumps to provide potable hot water needed for the store’s lavatory and restaurant operations.
“Tapping into geothermal technology is another way IKEA can maintain our commitment to sustainable building practices whenever feasible,” said Rob Parsons, IKEA Merriam store manager. “It also represents the values of the many Kansas City-area customers who are excited for us to open and complements our recent plans for solar panels atop the store.”
Consistent with the company’s goal of being energy independent by 2020, IKEA globally has installed more than 300,000 solar panels, owns/operates approximately 137 wind turbines in Europe, and has geothermal systems at approximately 50 locations. For the development, design and installation of the Merriam store’s customized geothermal project, IKEA contracted with Colorado-based Major Geothermal, a leading integrator of geothermal heat pump system design and installation, with experience on projects in Asia, Europe and North America.
This will be the company’s second United States store with geothermal. (The Denver-area IKEA Centennial opened with geothermal in 2011.)
UK: Heat pump manufacturers have welcomed the official extension to the Non-Domestic Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI), to now include air source heat pumps, following the announcement by the Department of Energy & Climate Change (DECC) on Wednesday 28 May 2014.
Under the incentive scheme companies receive regular payments for every kWh of renewable heat they use in their business, if generated by a ground, water or air source heat pump.
Tariffs are available for air source heat pumps at 2.5p/kWh and ground source heat pumps at a Tier 1 rate of 8.7p/kWh and Tier 2 rate of 2.6 p/kWh. Tier 1 is paid for the first 1,314 full-load equivalent hours and Tier 2 for all remaining output.
Businesses will receive a regular quarterly payment for the next 20 years, which provides long term and sustainable growth in the use of renewable technologies. The payments can amount to thousands of pounds
And help make the case for heat pumps much stronger, especially against traditional fossil fuel heating.
Eligibility of heat pumps
After the new regulations are introduced, applications submitted for ground-source and air-source heat pumps will be required to include the following:
Speaking at the ATMOsphere Europe 2013 Conference held in Brussels last week John Skelton F.Inst.R., Head of Refrigeration at Sainsbury’s, outlined the Company’s progress with regard to the installation of environmentally friendly RACHP technologies within their stores.
167 CO2 refrigeration installations
17 LED lighting installations
78 Biomass boilers
12 Closed Loop Geothermal Heating and Cooling Systems
129,000 Solar panels
25% of Petrol Station energy from solar photovoltaic panels (PV)
These initiatives form part of Sainsbury’s 20x20 Sustainability Plan of which ‘Respect for our environment’ is a key objective.
John Skelton joined Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Limited as an apprentice in 1984. He has spent his career in retail refrigeration working for and on behalf of various UK food retailers. He has been instrumental in reducing Sainsbury’s carbon footprint and the step change to CO2 refrigeration. John has delivered CO2 to over 160 stores and continues to champion the switch to natural refrigerant solutions.
In the first Fridgehub article on the subject of Geothermal/Ground Source Heat Pumps (18th September 2013) we outlined Sainsbury’s initiative to use this innovative technology to tap renewable energy from deep underground to provide energy efficient heating, hot water and cooling in a growing number of their supermarkets.
Fridgehub are privileged to have been granted permission by the Institute of Refrigeration to publish a case study written by John Skelton entitled “Closed Loop Geothermal Heating and Cooling for Supermarkets”.
In his introduction to the case study the author states that “The development of a closed loop geothermal heating and cooling system provided the ideal vehicle for Sainsbury’s to manage a store’s total carbon emissions whilst driving operational excellence”.
The case study describes the installation and energy performance of the integrated solution at Sainsbury’s store at Crayford, South East London (their first 100,000 sq. /ft. store)”.
Crayford was selected as a trial ‘carbon step change store’ as part of the Sainsbury’s business challenge to develop a lower carbon operational model. During 2010 the store’s sales area was being extended from 35,000 sq. /ft. to over 100,000 sq. /ft. and the challenge was set to achieve a zero absolute increase in the original store’s operational carbon footprint. An integrated geothermal system was selected to harness normally wasted store energy and to use it efficiently across the refrigeration and heating systems.
A key feature of this solution was that it required all of the delivery teams to change their normal ways of working from a design, installation and commissioning perspective. It was essential that the supply base drove the specification and worked collaboratively. In particular the collaboration between the disciplines of Refrigeration and Mechanical & Electrical engineering was critical to a successful outcome.
The system incorporates a primary circuit closed loop borehole system which provides access to the geothermal storage capacity of subsurface geology, adapting technology from the oil and gas drilling industry to utilise 15 x 200m deep boreholes.
The primary circuit which links the below ground boreholes to the refrigeration packs and the store heat pumps is filled with a glycol-water mix which exchanges geothermal energy due to the temperature differential with the surrounding geology. Due to the natural, relatively cool temperature of the ground a good condensing or cooling medium is delivered to the store’s refrigeration packs and heat pumps.
A secondary circuit delivers the store heating functions from the heat pumps, the performance of which is assisted by the rejected heat from the refrigeration packs.
The refrigeration packs are ‘standard’ Sainsbury’s CO2 with the addition of water to refrigerant heat exchangers in the refrigeration discharge circuit.
The heat pumps are fitted with water to refrigerant heat exchangers. The evaporator is supplied with the glycol-water mix from the borehole circuit, providing low grade heat. The condenser is connected to the store heating and hot water system and high quality heat produced by the compressors is rejected into a standard water-based circuit within the store which has enabled the requirement for natural gas to be discontinued.
Each of the working systems are sub-metered and monitored utilising the Sainsbury’s standard web-based system which enables both historical and cross-store comparisons. To ensure accuracy BSRIA were employed to check all of the monitoring points and calibrate and verify them, as well as to check the reporting/calculation methodology.
The first full year’s operation at Crayford delivered approximately a 55% energy saving in heating and refrigeration against an agreed benchmark for a like-sized store utilising standard systems (i.e. air-cooled CO2 refrigeration packs and gas boilers for heating).
The installation demonstrates that there are tangible benefits from considering a building’s carbon emissions as a ‘whole’ and ensuring the different engineering disciplines work together to reduce direct and indirect emissions, highlighting Sainsbury’s collaborative supplier philosophy. The Closed Loop Geothermal Heating and Cooling system at Crayford has delivered significant savings in refrigeration energy consumption, as well as a highly efficient ground source heating system to the store.
From the outset, this design concept was intended to be both sustainable and replicable, and as a result of the experience at Crayford the systems has now been implemented in an additional 11 Sainsbury’s stores during the past 3 years making a significant contribution to their 20 by 20 target of a 30% reduction in absolute operational carbon emissions by 2020 versus a baseline of 2005.
Many case study sessions that focus on cutting-edge natural refrigerant technologies and projects in the areas of industrial, commercial and transport refrigeration as well as heat pumps and air-conditioning were included at the ATMOsphere Europe 2013 Conference.
The full range of presentations from ATMOsphere Europe can be found on www.ATMO.org.
A geothermal heat pump or ground source heat pump (GSHP) is a central heating and/or cooling system that pumps heat to or from the ground. Ground source heat pumps harvest heat absorbed at the Earth's surface from solar energy. It uses the earth as a heat source (in the winter) or a heat sink (in the summer). This design takes advantage of the moderate temperatures in the ground to boost efficiency and reduce the operational costs of heating and cooling systems, and may be combined with solar heating to form a geosolar system with even greater efficiency. Ground source heat pumps are also known as "geothermal heat pumps" although, strictly, the heat does not come from the centre of the Earth, but from the Sun.
Ground source heat pumps use pipes which are buried in the ground to extract heat from the ground. This heat can then be used to heat radiators, underfloor or warm air heating systems and hot water in a building.
A ground source heat pump circulates a mixture of water and antifreeze around a loop of pipe – called a ground loop – which is buried in the ground outside the building. Heat from the ground is absorbed into the fluid and then passes through a heat exchanger into the heat pump. The ground stays at a fairly constant temperature under the surface, so the heat pump can be used throughout the year – even in the middle of winter.
The length of the ground loop depends on the size of the building and the amount of heat needed. Longer loops can draw more heat from the ground, but need more space to be buried in. If space is limited, a vertical borehole can be drilled instead.
The benefits of installing a ground source heat pump (GSHP) include:
Unlike gas and oil boilers, heat pumps deliver heat at lower temperatures over much longer periods. During the winter they may need to be on constantly to heat the building efficiently. Occupants will also notice that radiators won't feel as hot to the touch as they might do when using a gas or oil boiler.
Heat from the ground is absorbed at low temperatures into a fluid inside a loop of pipe (a ground loop) buried underground. The fluid then passes through a compressor that raises it to a higher temperature, which can then heat water for the heating and hot water circuits of the house. The cooled ground-loop fluid passes back into the ground where it absorbs further energy from the ground in a continuous process as long as heating is required.
Normally the loop is laid flat or coiled in trenches about two metres deep, but if there is not enough space a vertical loop down into the ground can be installed to a depth of up to 100 metres. Heat pumps have some impact on the environment as they need electricity to run, but the heat they extract from the ground, the air, or water is constantly being renewed naturally.
In July, retail giant Sainsbury’s launched the installation of their 12th Ground Source Heat Pump at their store at London Colney in St. Albans. They have showcased their use of this innovative technology that taps renewable energy from deep underground to provide energy efficient heating, hot water and cooling for the stores. The roll out of Ground Source Heat Pumps at 12 stores follows Sainsbury’s successful world-first use of the geo-thermal technology at its Crayford store, enabling it to supply 30 per cent of its energy from on-site renewable sources. It has also installed 74 biomass boilers since 2008, which use wood pellets - a renewable resource - to heat stores rather than using fossil fuel-based gas.
The Ground Source Heat Pump Association - The Association provides information on GSHPs via a this website and telephone helplines and makes presentations to promote the ground source industry to key audiences.
Energy Savings Trust – Advice to homeowners on Ground Source Heat Pumps, installation, financial benefits, Planning permissions.
B&ES - Ground Source Heat Pump Guidance - Great resources that will provide more detail on Ground Source Heat Pumps
B&ES – TR 30 - The first part of the forthcoming suite of TR30 publications, this looks at different applications of Heat Pumps technology. It provides generic installation requirements for a range of renewable energy systems including biomass fuels, solar hot water and combined heat and power (CHP).
Image Credit: Advance NRG www.advancenrg.com
This article is brought to you by Fridgehub – a major new industry website for manufacturers, distributers, service providers, operators and consumers of refrigeration, air conditioning and heat-pump (RACHP) products and services.
Follow @theFridgehub on Twitter